why in this statement we can use both oldest and eldest.
i think it should be oldest only, am i right?
emanahmed
I think we can use both words because It is a personal pronom, It´s means that refers only a people: I.
MARYCARMEN
I have the same problem. Help us, please :)
Rodzyn
Here we are talking about the person. So we can use either Oldest or Eldest
Jeevan
Hi, Alex. I agree with emanahmed because of what you explained about absolutes. Isn’t this case an example of absolutes (superlative)? Thanx a bunch!!
jafcru12
No, my friend we can use both of them. because we can use oldest and eldest when we talk about people. is it clear?
Elvin
No, my friend we can use both of them. Because, we can use oldest and eldest when we talk about people. is it clear?
elvin580
Dear emanahmed,
Ur not right!U know, we can use oldest n eldest 2 talk about people n as it’s clear in the quiz we can also use both in superlatives n absolutes.Otherwise they the samne meaning n there’s no matter 2 use both in the blank.
Hope I could help!
fatiima8
Fatima, If so, take this case: Ryan Giggs is the ___ player on Manchester United. The correct answer is: older (not both). I still do not understand.
jafcru12
ups..Sorry I meant to write oldest (not older).
jafcru12
….but my answer is still on BOTH.,
bcoz “the player” is person n both(oldest n eldest)r usable in my book!
U can search more.
Goodluck!
fatiima8
Yes. I think You’re right,completely right
Ubirajara Paulo da Silva
You can use oldest or eldest but the sentence should be
1)I’m the oldest/eldest among my siblings.
2)I’m the oldest/eldest of 4 siblings.
(no need to add the word family because a sibling is already part of a family
dess
I agree with you! If there is a pronoum “the”, we should use only “oldest”, isn´t there?
alexdiscacciati@gmail.com
It is good iunderstood clearly,thanks a lot.
shahnazparveen
Can we use this sentence, ‘ she the eldest women live in the this oldest town’. Tq
noramizi
No we can’t use the sentance. It should be “She is the oldestt women lives in oldest city”
Jeevan
Dear Jeevan,
Ur sentence is not totally correct;
It’s:She’s the oldest/eldest womAn (not womEn) lives in the oldest town.
As it’s in the quiz,we can use both the oldest n the eldest in absolutes n superlatives sentences.
Goodluck!
fatiima8
Actually I don’t suppose your sentence totally correct. I think I should be “She is the oldest woman LIVING in the oldest city”.
Sebert
Thanks for this instruction ,I just didn´t understand the use of (both)
Please help me
antonio britto
thanks alex
mshmsh
thanks Alex
asadalifaizi
mr Alex u r a great teacher.
God bless u
thank u so much!!!!!
sony
I haven’t heard eldest, now I know thanks a bunch Alex.
Efrain
HI Alex! u ar a great teacher :) I was your real student in ALI last summer so very very nice to see you there!:)
MariaK
thanks Alex………. I had not heard the word sibling. i want to ask you: there is more comun to say sibling instead of brother and sister ?
jesusangel
thanks u are very nice
bernadette
Alex. I do not agree with the rsult of first, third and four question because the answer is both for all of them and the result say that oldest is correct???????/
CREBIO
it was a new knowledge for me that oldest and eldest can be used for brothers/sisters. I thought that we can use only eldest among brothers/sisters
raji kumar
I always knew that we use ELDEST for memeber of our family.
Karina
Thanks for changing the flag Engvid :)
maher10
Thanks so much Alex
junetran208
Hi Alex, great lesson.
could you explain us, why is there a difference between following sentences:
“Ryan Giggs is the oldest player on Manchester United.”
and
“I am the oldest/eldest sibling in my family.”
thanks
Igor
She’s the _________ of four siblings.
I am the __________ sibling in my family.
This is confused me ..Why should I use both oldest and eldest if there is “The”
Thanks Alex :)
Sahar
Thanks for such a great lesson. I got full mark :))
Beginner
Thanks teacher.
mursaleen45
Good! It is first time that I got perfect for quiz.
masa58
Dear Alex
you should not use “Green Pilot” on the whiteboard, because we cannot see properly,try blue and black please, thanks for the classes
aleklawa
Dear Alex thanks alot for this.
basitali110
Dear Alex again I would ask you the same that how we can use both, oldest and eldest,in last statement? As there is THE…
basitali110
thank u so much teacher alex >>>
shuraimatiq
thank you somuch that great i revised that withe my eldest brother he said that good
mohamed
Thank You, Alex!, you are a good teacher!
héctor
thank you Alex I always listen to your lessons but I want you to do more in vocabulary .
ABDULRAHIM HAMID
thanks …….it’s very useful 4 me…..
qiya
Thanks
Aschelove
thank you so much teachers
thank you so much engvid.com
hello friands if anyone want to talk in english to practice send me massege gibrahim200@hotmail.com
gibrahim200
thank you Alex
riadona
Thanks a lot !!!
bink
Dear Vallen Teacher,
I wish to study from you I am an employee of a transporting company I have just studied intermediate, but failed In my young period I did not give any interest to study on now I am struggling for that while my I have to send emails & letters always. Could you
help me, then mail me
Nasar
Thank you!
kentiya
thank you teacher
nawel
When i have been a student, we used to use these two words in a different way. When we spoke about the age we used the the word “old”, but when we spoke about family members, and we wanted to emphasize the fact that somebody was born previously, we used the second variant such as “elder, the eldest. For example: This woman is older than that one. or This is my elder brother. I think that this distinction is more appropriate. Even Raymond Murphy gives the same explanation. Maybe i am wrong, but i am also a teacher of English and i have read a lot of different grammar books and i have never heard that “older and elder” are equal in meanings. Our teacher was from the USA and when instead of “elder” we used “older” with people it was considered as a huge mistake!!!
snejka08
Good lesson with great difficulties because there’s many and different explanations about this topic
surenkhach95
i do not understand the oldest person to ever live. why i cannot use the eldest.and about player why can not use the eldest.these are about person. thanks.
jo9142
thanks for your good lesson that was understandible
eng.adam
thank you Alex
prashanthy
Dear Alex, question 3&4 is recommended about people, so I choose answer “both” but why it’s false? I can’t understand? Please help me?
tin
Oh, i understand now, thanks you for your video.
tin
Ryan Giggs is the ________________ player on Manchester United.
why can’t both be used here?
john
I was wrong NO.3and No.4.
The ( ) person… why is “both” wrong? And No.4 too
patrick22
Thanks for this free lesson. I am learning a lot.
honey
thx 4 the lesson this is the first time i know wt’s the different between oldest and eldest
doda
thanks for the topic .. you explained it very well.
hannazis23
Thanks!! :D
Eve
great lesson
alialnamah1978
thnx for lesson mr alex
ahmedmohamed88
it is a extremely mind blowing technique……..
THANKS ALEX…….
kaushal bahuguna
mr alex is the greatest teacher’yes you’re right it’s oldest only good job!!!
synthychndaya
Dear Alex,
“As far as” VS “So far as”
Those combination of words confuses me.
The both have the same translation.
Could you please explain me difference in their application?
grenadier
Wow! Great teacher. keep it up!
Sara
Thanks for your good lesson,it makes me more understand.
chadaporn
whoaa.. i wasn’t unsure about the differences between those two words, now i do…thank you teacher!! :D
Didi
thanks for lesson!
lev77
I like your course,Alex.thank you so much.
rabbit
Well, I was lil worse in grammer. but now-a-days takin quiz and watchin engvid improved me. thanks a lot!!! ^_^ <3<3
Oyo Lhamo
firstly,I thank all the group teachers.believe me if i said that all your lessons are helpful. and they’ll assist not only students but anyone had a desire to improve his/her language.i’m a moroccan english student .I send you many salute. please; could you do some videos about how to lecture ,I mean how to deliver a presentation? thanks ,take care;cheerio
abdou kaka
hi alex! someone hacked you facebook account, and starts to talk to me asking for money..
take care
gonzalo
I have been studying English at school but now I am thinking leave it and use that time to attend your lessons. You explain exelente, I’m agree, you are doing a great job!!
salbix
thanks alex
zeze714
many thanks to you
liosso
thanx
ekramalamri
i love this link a lot!! thanks.. it’s very useful for me!!
mei
thanx Alex
Maha
Good Lesson! Thank you!
lucasleitao
Thanks sir,I really known difference between oldest and eldest and now next I will be not confuse when I use to this word,Thanks once again
shakir
Way 2 go!
fatiima8
Could you explain this
I am the __________ sibling in my family.
oldest
eldest
both
the answer is both…
why…???
jamilah
U know…both r correct bcoz we can use both eldest n oldest 2 talk about people n sibling is a person.
Glad I could help!
fatiima8
Shouldn’t the answer of both questions no.3 and no.4 be (both)?
hey alex would you plz make a video on use of would in future
azra22
“absolute” and “superlative” don’t matter. eldest can be used for any group of related persons, especially relatives or the same family. in reality, it is mostly only used in reference to siblings.
#3: the group if people live in the world. it is not a family.
#4: players belonging to Manchester United is not a family.
#5: it refers to relative.
#7: it refers to siblings.
#10: it also refers to siblings.
marronfield
Thank you Alex
muhanad
Hi Alex, Thanks for your lesson. As many people asked before, I neither understand why in the quiz the answers of the questions 3 and 4 are “oldest” and not “both”? Jeanne Calment and Ryan Giggs are both people… Please explain it to us!!
milly
thanks dear teacher I have a question please
May I use only eldest if it is fit for both people and things so I will be free and get red of the grammar problems
preemy
HI Alex,
Your lessons are incredibly interesting. I have a terrible confusion regarding usage of Although, yet or still in one single sentence. Can these be used?
Thanks
Abe
thanks a lot for this lesson.
I have a question, why we can not use both in the following sentence?
The __________ person to ever live was named Jeanne Calment. She was from France, and died at the age of 122.
oldest
eldest
both
riad85
Thanks
Reza
Thanks a lot Alex for your time and effort, and I have a question on this lesson, you mentioned that Oldest can be used person, things and absolutes, it means that for superlatives we are just allowed to use Oldest where there is The ….before that so why we can see the opposites in the examples?
Soheila
thank you very much for such interesting lesson
argenis
Thank you so much.
Thuong
thank you for this lesson.i understood everything about this grammar rule but except -both-
sevinc
Thanks Alex. I got 90%. It was very interesting.You are the One !
Angel
thanks Alex, I got 90%! Very good lesson!
Sally S
hi Alex. i have some confusion about the differences between ‘convince’ and ‘persuade’. could you explain more clearly for me, plz?
huyen
really all your lessons help a lot , many thanks :)
raj12dec88
This lesson helped me, thanks!
sgmmm
Hi teacher Alex. In my opinion i’m the oldest student in your class.Cheers from Athens!!
pafsilipoclub
Alex,I haven’t known the difference before.I am a bit confused.My score is 90.Thanks alot.Take care.
daffodile
Thank you Alex, great lesson.
Dorian Garcia
thaaaaaaaaaaannk you :)
Assinate
Hi Alex. What did you mean exactly by absolute? I did not understand the meaning fella! And by the way, you’re my favourite! Your lessons are quite informative. You’re helping me to become a knowledgeable teacher! Glad to meet you! A feather in my cap!
mohamadastro
Nice hairstyle.
Aekanta
Yes this is a great lesson thanks
Sultani
I gess you’re right. In superlative form we use only oldest. The same situation is in the 7th sentence “She’s the _________ of four siblings”. But is possible, I am not understand this lesson.
gmostek
Thanks a lot, Mr Alex! Useful lesson!!!
Ip Man Lee
90%.
Abdul Qayum
thanks a lot, this lesson is very useful
moezbesbes
what are absolutes?
Ayush Parakh
Hi Alex! Would you explain the answers in items 7 & 10, please? I’ve chosen the oldest but the right answers are “both”…
Michael Zelenko
Hi Alex, As for the exercise above, I’m a little bit confused as you said that in superlative we rather use oldest so why in question 10 and 7, it should be both versions are correct answer? Thanks Radek
radeks
thank you very much!!! :)
mvd777
Dear Alex till now we do not have your answer on the absolute. What is right?. To use oldest as u mentioned in your tutorial or both oldest and eldest? Please, we are waiting for your answer
elsharkawi
ty buut there’s itty-bitty
don’t u tell us that we use oldest when we talk about superlative”
kotoz
Why Mr.Kotoz ?
Adwait Shiva
I love Alex”s lessons
Adwait Shiva
Thanks a lot Alex!
Jonathas Wilhem
Thanks!
shihai182
Thank you Mr. Alex.
Alex-1956
well, the number 7 is weird but I was trying to understand this and I have read about this topic. Maybe Alex forgot to explain us but there is a rule where eldest can be used when we are talking about family and it is the case.
Learn English for free with 2130 video lessons by experienced teachers. Classes cover English grammar, vocabulary, pronunciation, IELTS, TOEFL, and more. Join millions of English learners worldwide who are improving every day with engVid.
145 COMMENTS
I am the __________ sibling in my family.
why in this statement we can use both oldest and eldest.
i think it should be oldest only, am i right?
I think we can use both words because It is a personal pronom, It´s means that refers only a people: I.
I have the same problem. Help us, please :)
Here we are talking about the person. So we can use either Oldest or Eldest
Hi, Alex. I agree with emanahmed because of what you explained about absolutes. Isn’t this case an example of absolutes (superlative)? Thanx a bunch!!
No, my friend we can use both of them. because we can use oldest and eldest when we talk about people. is it clear?
No, my friend we can use both of them. Because, we can use oldest and eldest when we talk about people. is it clear?
Dear emanahmed,
Ur not right!U know, we can use oldest n eldest 2 talk about people n as it’s clear in the quiz we can also use both in superlatives n absolutes.Otherwise they the samne meaning n there’s no matter 2 use both in the blank.
Hope I could help!
Fatima, If so, take this case: Ryan Giggs is the ___ player on Manchester United. The correct answer is: older (not both). I still do not understand.
ups..Sorry I meant to write oldest (not older).
….but my answer is still on BOTH.,
bcoz “the player” is person n both(oldest n eldest)r usable in my book!
U can search more.
Goodluck!
Yes. I think You’re right,completely right
You can use oldest or eldest but the sentence should be
1)I’m the oldest/eldest among my siblings.
2)I’m the oldest/eldest of 4 siblings.
(no need to add the word family because a sibling is already part of a family
I agree with you! If there is a pronoum “the”, we should use only “oldest”, isn´t there?
It is good iunderstood clearly,thanks a lot.
Can we use this sentence, ‘ she the eldest women live in the this oldest town’. Tq
No we can’t use the sentance. It should be “She is the oldestt women lives in oldest city”
Dear Jeevan,
Ur sentence is not totally correct;
It’s:She’s the oldest/eldest womAn (not womEn) lives in the oldest town.
As it’s in the quiz,we can use both the oldest n the eldest in absolutes n superlatives sentences.
Goodluck!
Actually I don’t suppose your sentence totally correct. I think I should be “She is the oldest woman LIVING in the oldest city”.
Thanks for this instruction ,I just didn´t understand the use of (both)
Please help me
thanks alex
thanks Alex
mr Alex u r a great teacher.
God bless u
thank u so much!!!!!
I haven’t heard eldest, now I know thanks a bunch Alex.
HI Alex! u ar a great teacher :) I was your real student in ALI last summer so very very nice to see you there!:)
thanks Alex………. I had not heard the word sibling. i want to ask you: there is more comun to say sibling instead of brother and sister ?
thanks u are very nice
Alex. I do not agree with the rsult of first, third and four question because the answer is both for all of them and the result say that oldest is correct???????/
it was a new knowledge for me that oldest and eldest can be used for brothers/sisters. I thought that we can use only eldest among brothers/sisters
I always knew that we use ELDEST for memeber of our family.
Thanks for changing the flag Engvid :)
Thanks so much Alex
Hi Alex, great lesson.
could you explain us, why is there a difference between following sentences:
“Ryan Giggs is the oldest player on Manchester United.”
and
“I am the oldest/eldest sibling in my family.”
thanks
She’s the _________ of four siblings.
I am the __________ sibling in my family.
This is confused me ..Why should I use both oldest and eldest if there is “The”
Thanks Alex :)
Thanks for such a great lesson. I got full mark :))
Thanks teacher.
Good! It is first time that I got perfect for quiz.
Dear Alex
you should not use “Green Pilot” on the whiteboard, because we cannot see properly,try blue and black please, thanks for the classes
Dear Alex thanks alot for this.
Dear Alex again I would ask you the same that how we can use both, oldest and eldest,in last statement? As there is THE…
thank u so much teacher alex >>>
thank you somuch that great i revised that withe my eldest brother he said that good
Thank You, Alex!, you are a good teacher!
thank you Alex I always listen to your lessons but I want you to do more in vocabulary .
thanks …….it’s very useful 4 me…..
Thanks
thank you so much teachers
thank you so much engvid.com
hello friands if anyone want to talk in english to practice send me massege gibrahim200@hotmail.com
thank you Alex
Thanks a lot !!!
Dear Vallen Teacher,
I wish to study from you I am an employee of a transporting company I have just studied intermediate, but failed In my young period I did not give any interest to study on now I am struggling for that while my I have to send emails & letters always. Could you
help me, then mail me
Thank you!
thank you teacher
When i have been a student, we used to use these two words in a different way. When we spoke about the age we used the the word “old”, but when we spoke about family members, and we wanted to emphasize the fact that somebody was born previously, we used the second variant such as “elder, the eldest. For example: This woman is older than that one. or This is my elder brother. I think that this distinction is more appropriate. Even Raymond Murphy gives the same explanation. Maybe i am wrong, but i am also a teacher of English and i have read a lot of different grammar books and i have never heard that “older and elder” are equal in meanings. Our teacher was from the USA and when instead of “elder” we used “older” with people it was considered as a huge mistake!!!
Good lesson with great difficulties because there’s many and different explanations about this topic
i do not understand the oldest person to ever live. why i cannot use the eldest.and about player why can not use the eldest.these are about person. thanks.
thanks for your good lesson that was understandible
thank you Alex
Dear Alex, question 3&4 is recommended about people, so I choose answer “both” but why it’s false? I can’t understand? Please help me?
Oh, i understand now, thanks you for your video.
Ryan Giggs is the ________________ player on Manchester United.
why can’t both be used here?
I was wrong NO.3and No.4.
The ( ) person… why is “both” wrong? And No.4 too
Thanks for this free lesson. I am learning a lot.
thx 4 the lesson this is the first time i know wt’s the different between oldest and eldest
thanks for the topic .. you explained it very well.
Thanks!! :D
great lesson
thnx for lesson mr alex
it is a extremely mind blowing technique……..
THANKS ALEX…….
mr alex is the greatest teacher’yes you’re right it’s oldest only good job!!!
Dear Alex,
“As far as” VS “So far as”
Those combination of words confuses me.
The both have the same translation.
Could you please explain me difference in their application?
Wow! Great teacher. keep it up!
Thanks for your good lesson,it makes me more understand.
whoaa.. i wasn’t unsure about the differences between those two words, now i do…thank you teacher!! :D
thanks for lesson!
I like your course,Alex.thank you so much.
Well, I was lil worse in grammer. but now-a-days takin quiz and watchin engvid improved me. thanks a lot!!! ^_^ <3<3
firstly,I thank all the group teachers.believe me if i said that all your lessons are helpful. and they’ll assist not only students but anyone had a desire to improve his/her language.i’m a moroccan english student .I send you many salute. please; could you do some videos about how to lecture ,I mean how to deliver a presentation? thanks ,take care;cheerio
hi alex! someone hacked you facebook account, and starts to talk to me asking for money..
take care
I have been studying English at school but now I am thinking leave it and use that time to attend your lessons. You explain exelente, I’m agree, you are doing a great job!!
thanks alex
many thanks to you
thanx
i love this link a lot!! thanks.. it’s very useful for me!!
thanx Alex
Good Lesson! Thank you!
Thanks sir,I really known difference between oldest and eldest and now next I will be not confuse when I use to this word,Thanks once again
Way 2 go!
Could you explain this
I am the __________ sibling in my family.
oldest
eldest
both
the answer is both…
why…???
U know…both r correct bcoz we can use both eldest n oldest 2 talk about people n sibling is a person.
Glad I could help!
Shouldn’t the answer of both questions no.3 and no.4 be (both)?
Can i get the basic tutorials
Here’s a link to all our beginner-level lessons.
Hi Alex
Thank u to teach us
I scored 9 out of 10
thanks alot
ha make two mistake :( its question 3 and 4 why are there answer oldest and not’t both? where are personal used I don’t understand
Thanks a lot Mr. Alex for clarifying the difference between eldest and oldest.
I’ve never understood the difference between oldest and eldest…you’ve explained so well…so I don’t have any doubts, now. Thank you for your class
Thanks a lot!!
Great job, Really!!
VERY CONFUSING GUESENT
thanks Alex.. Very good lesson!
HI ELVIRA35
LETS KEEP IN TOUCH ..ADD ON MSN aleklawa@hotmail.com
Very nice, thank you
good one
hey alex would you plz make a video on use of would in future
“absolute” and “superlative” don’t matter. eldest can be used for any group of related persons, especially relatives or the same family. in reality, it is mostly only used in reference to siblings.
#3: the group if people live in the world. it is not a family.
#4: players belonging to Manchester United is not a family.
#5: it refers to relative.
#7: it refers to siblings.
#10: it also refers to siblings.
Thank you Alex
Hi Alex, Thanks for your lesson. As many people asked before, I neither understand why in the quiz the answers of the questions 3 and 4 are “oldest” and not “both”? Jeanne Calment and Ryan Giggs are both people… Please explain it to us!!
thanks dear teacher I have a question please
May I use only eldest if it is fit for both people and things so I will be free and get red of the grammar problems
HI Alex,
Your lessons are incredibly interesting. I have a terrible confusion regarding usage of Although, yet or still in one single sentence. Can these be used?
Thanks
thanks a lot for this lesson.
I have a question, why we can not use both in the following sentence?
The __________ person to ever live was named Jeanne Calment. She was from France, and died at the age of 122.
oldest
eldest
both
Thanks
Thanks a lot Alex for your time and effort, and I have a question on this lesson, you mentioned that Oldest can be used person, things and absolutes, it means that for superlatives we are just allowed to use Oldest where there is The ….before that so why we can see the opposites in the examples?
thank you very much for such interesting lesson
Thank you so much.
thank you for this lesson.i understood everything about this grammar rule but except -both-
Thanks Alex. I got 90%. It was very interesting.You are the One !
thanks Alex, I got 90%! Very good lesson!
hi Alex. i have some confusion about the differences between ‘convince’ and ‘persuade’. could you explain more clearly for me, plz?
really all your lessons help a lot , many thanks :)
This lesson helped me, thanks!
Hi teacher Alex. In my opinion i’m the oldest student in your class.Cheers from Athens!!
Alex,I haven’t known the difference before.I am a bit confused.My score is 90.Thanks alot.Take care.
Thank you Alex, great lesson.
thaaaaaaaaaaannk you :)
Hi Alex. What did you mean exactly by absolute? I did not understand the meaning fella! And by the way, you’re my favourite! Your lessons are quite informative. You’re helping me to become a knowledgeable teacher! Glad to meet you! A feather in my cap!
Nice hairstyle.
Yes this is a great lesson thanks
I gess you’re right. In superlative form we use only oldest. The same situation is in the 7th sentence “She’s the _________ of four siblings”. But is possible, I am not understand this lesson.
Thanks a lot, Mr Alex! Useful lesson!!!
90%.
thanks a lot, this lesson is very useful
what are absolutes?
Hi Alex! Would you explain the answers in items 7 & 10, please? I’ve chosen the oldest but the right answers are “both”…
Hi Alex, As for the exercise above, I’m a little bit confused as you said that in superlative we rather use oldest so why in question 10 and 7, it should be both versions are correct answer? Thanks Radek
thank you very much!!! :)
Dear Alex till now we do not have your answer on the absolute. What is right?. To use oldest as u mentioned in your tutorial or both oldest and eldest? Please, we are waiting for your answer
ty buut there’s itty-bitty
don’t u tell us that we use oldest when we talk about superlative”
Why Mr.Kotoz ?
I love Alex”s lessons
Thanks a lot Alex!
Thanks!
Thank you Mr. Alex.
well, the number 7 is weird but I was trying to understand this and I have read about this topic. Maybe Alex forgot to explain us but there is a rule where eldest can be used when we are talking about family and it is the case.
and the same for number 10.
8/10