Adam
Alex
Benjamin
Emma
Gill
Jade
James
Rebecca
Ronnie
That & Which
Learn when to use “that” and “which,” and listen to a review of the two types of relative clauses. Commas are important and can change the entire meaning of a sentence! Make sure to also watch my lesson on relative clauses.
Quiz
Test your understanding of this English lesson
Test your understanding of the English lesson by answering these questions. You will get the answers and your score at the end of the quiz.Levels
Lesson Topics
294 COMMENTS
A great lesson.
Nice lesson
a great lesson for me to learn spoken english. keep up the great work!
good lesson, i wanna ask about the first question in the quiz : how the comma and that together in this sentence
thanks you lessen.i”m from sri lanka.i need to learn english.pleas help me .tthanks you
I am from Sri Lanka as well, but i think you need more than help right now. What do you mean by “thanks you lesson”.
no insult plz
Thank`s a lot for filling that gap in my knowledge
Hi there people, what happened to the quiz? there is no quiz to answer.
very good teacher ,very good lesson,
It’s a great lesson that i learned. But I have a problem. I saw a speeding car, that really startled me. You have taught after the “,” it should be “which”.Please reply me. Thank you very much.
Yes, it is strange also for me to write ”that” after the comma in this sentence.
thanks alex.the lesson was very useful for me before taking proficiency exam:)
Hi zaynab could you speak with me on my hot mail please i want to improve my english
Regards
can you understand when we you use that and which? i am confused right now and i will attend cope exam
hi..whats your name
hi mr alex Could you clarify what is required of this question
The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
and thank you a lot for this lesson also for Adverb Clauses .
comfused
great…thank you dear ALex :)
hello sir,the lesson is good1 but i don’t know what happened my computer isn’t showing any quiz below the video……….
Hi Alex thank very much for English class,it is a lot help for me .
thanks for an awesome lesson!
thanks iam happy to do this quiz
t :)hank you
Hi Alex,
nice lesson. But,I can’t understand quiz no.1. could you explain?
i also have question like you. the lesson “relative clause” showed very clearly that after “,” have to use which but the 1st question is in stark contrast. I need a explanation please
Hey Alex, Please reply to this ambiguity that we all are facing…
Hello I think that I can explain it for you the first sentence is written I saw a speeding car, which really startled me. now I saw a speeding car don’t lose any meaning by itself that’s beacause ,which really startled me is an extra information in other words is a non-identifying clause. the second sentence says I saw a speeding car, that really startled me. now we have to select this because “that” can only be used inside an identifying clause I hope that helps you.
great lesson ,although I am a little bit confused….
I failed the quiz, holycows, I never thought that will be true. 5 out of 10. what a nightmare.
I like it very much, thank you, is there any
means to improve my English my native language
Ehiopian language called Amharic
LOVE IT ;)
thank Alex,that’s what l needed.we need more.
hi elex i dont understand how way use that and which so much you can explain more detail for me .I hope you soon answer .thanks verry much
thanks alot Teacher…
hi elex ,
7 out of 10
i cloud not understand this sentences. what this sentences means. please let me know.
The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
Hi, Alex!
I’ve got one question concerning the quiz.
Why is the sentence “I saw a speeding car, that really startled me” correct, and “I saw a speeding car, which really startled me” is not? I thought that a comma shouldn’t be used in an identifying clause…
I thought the same! Was the only question I missed…
As I can suggest, we all, including me, are very inattentive. It is asked in a question: What is incorrect (not correct)?
because we have to select the incorrect sentence.
the lesson that i took was great..lesson,which i took was great…
that and which was hard and un understandable it should be explan more easy way
This site helps a lot of people especially those who have challenge on communication skills.
The lesson that or which you taught us was really useful,thanks a lot….
Exciting…
Nice Lesson
thank you for this lesson
thank you alex was a great lesson ;)
hi, what is the difference in meaning between these sentences:
i had written the word
i have written the word
i wrote the word
and when should i use each one?
thanks. i hope i get the answer
thanks for your good lessons and also your fantastic method
THANKS ALEX
God bless you , it is useful lesson going on :)
Respected Alex Sir
Lectures that you have provided are excellent. I am grateful to you. I am passionate about English. I live in India. I want to learn English. Please guide me. Where can I get the resources? Suggest me some books/links.
your student
Deepak
First time I am clear about usage of that and which..
The lesson that I just saw it’s really useful. Keep up the good work. :D
Do anyone know how can I use this quiz? When I click on the quiz below video, nothing happens. :S
Maybe is a stupid question but…Do I have to pay for it? :S
Thanx Alex, greeting from Bosnia&Herzegovina.
I really appreciate this website. Congrats.
I just have one doubt. Could you explain the first question of the quiz?
1.Which sentence is incorrect?
a)I saw a speeding car, which really startled me.
b)I saw a speeding car, that really startled me.
I thought it was letter a) but the answer is letter b).
Why?
They asked which one is incorrect, so we need to answer the wrong one.
nice lesson,thanks!
i got 7 out of 10 and i don’t really understand Q8 and Q9
Please let me know if the first answer to the quiz is right or wrong .
I saw a speeding car, which really startled me. wrong?
I saw a speeding car, that really startled me.
The answer indicates this is right, but I think it should be wrong!
Is the rule based on comas or meaning?
If in commas, when “that” is used should be no commas.
Thank you!
Ok alex,very good ….
I get 8 answer correct..
thank you
Mario
Great work, Alex!
Dear Mr. Alex please tell us which time we use as and which time like in the sentences thanks
ilove these website engvid becuse in here i can to learn english ok thanx for all
Thank you for this useful lesson.
It is very interesant lesson.
thanks
Alex…
MR ALEX THX 4 this great lesson, but i haven’t understood why we put the second choices 4 “The book which cost $15 was my favourite.” and “The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.”please could u elucidate more?????
nice lesson
nice this lesson
hi mr.Alex iam eman from egypt thanks about this lesson ,I can,t understand this lesson 100percent ,bec.Ican,t diffrence between adverb clauses and indenty clauses please tell me how i diffrence between it,thanks.
Mr. Alex,
I didn’t know that different between “which” or “that” before I saw this lesson. Thanks.
I feel more happy if teacher’s of engVid.com add some more tricks in tutorials and make the duration of Video bit longer. Thanks and Regards.
The lesson was really useful, thank you, Alex!
it was not that good sorry to tell you
What crazy you are! The lessons are very useful to most of students who participated in this website. Why do you think that?
you my pretty little thing tell me something, what do you really mean ‘it was not that good’.
It was great
i wish this game help me to edify my communication skill.
teachers, please help me.
thanks
it was an awesome lesson. And great explanation with simple and easily understandable examples.
thanx alot mr.Alex…..
this site is being very very useful for me,thanks to this site i´m improving my english very fast,great lessons thanks alex.canadian english is better to understand than britsh and american english,my english is bad but i can understand 90% of what you say your pronunciation is perfect to understand for begginers like me
could you tell me what is difficulty between identifying clause and non-identifying clause, please!thank Alex for your lession.
oh! boy give the guy a rest, that is exactly what he was explaining in the lesson.just grow up my boy.
Thank you Alex
thank you so much, that was pretty much helpful :)
How can the answer to the speeding car question not be ‘which’. If the clause is identifying then either ‘tha’t or ‘which’ should be correct but if it is a non identifying clause then ‘which’ would be correct. But I’m told that ‘that’ is correct and ‘which’ is wrong. Did I miss something in the lesson ?
i use which in all incidents instead of that then problem is solved
Hey Alex, thanks for your undoubtedly useful lessons ! keep up e good work! But, there’s sth that i’m confused about. How do u know when to use which and that ? e.g qns1 in e quiz ; I saw a speeding car, that really startled me? Help Help help help plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
Thanks for the video, but I didn’t really understand the three questions at the end of the quiz: The book which cost $15 was my favourite.
~I bought one book.
~I bought more than one book.
The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
~I am baking one cake.
~I am baking more than one cake.
The tea, which I bought yesterday, is peppermint.
~I bought one kind of tea.
~I bought more than one kind of tea.
Can you please explain what they mean? Thanks a lot!
hi sir give me a info abt how can i make a sentence in English i hav not make a sence in this plz give me a easy pattren /methed ty :)
nice lesson thank you
That’s great easy to understand. Thanks
Употребление слов which и that часто вызывает трудности, так как оба варианта вводят придаточные предложения и переводятся одинаково – который.
Рассмотрим два примера.
The movie that (which) we saw last weekend was really good. – Кино, которое мы посмотрели на прошлых выходных, было действительно хорошим.
Harry Potter, which I finished last week, was an axcellent book. – Гарри Поттер, которого я закончил на прошлой недели, отличная книга.
Как видите, мы показали, что в первом предложении возможны оба варианты, но во втором только один. Почему? Сейчас разберемся. Давайте из первого примера уберем придаточное предложение, вводимое that и which: The movie was really good (Кино было действительно хорошим). Какое кино? Что за кино? Для понимания предложения нам требуется конкретизирующая информация. Союзы that и which как раз предназначены для ввода конкретизирующей информации, без которой предложение невозможно полноценно понять. Как вы догадались, в случае с необходимой для понимания информации можно использовать оба союза.
Обратимся ко второму примеру и поступим с ним так же, как и с первым – уберем из него придаточное предложение: Harry Potter was an axcellent book (Гарри Поттер – отличная книга.) Согласитесь, что мы не будем задавать вопросы типа – Кто такой Гарри Поттер? Мы все знаем, кто такой Гарри Поттер, и нам не требуется конкретизирующая информация. Мы вполне можем обойтись без придаточного предложения. В данном случае придаточное предложение выполняет функцию не конкретизирующую, а сообщающую дополнительную (избыточную) информацию, и в этом случае следует использовать только союз which.
Рассмотрим еще примеры.
The table which (that) I bought from Ikea was cheap. – Стол, который я купил в Икеа, был дешевым.
Toronto, which is heavily populated, is a multicultural city. – Торонто, который является плотно населенным, многокультурный город.
Давайте уберем из первого примера придаточное предложение: The table was cheap (Стол был дешевым.) Какой стол? Что за стол? Требуется конкретизирующая информация, которую можно ввести либо при помощи союза which, либо that.
Теперь из второго примеры изымем придаточное предложение: Toronto is a multicultural city (Торонто – многокультурный город.) Получившееся предложение самодостаточно, т.е. нам не требуется никакая информация для его понимания. То, что вводится придаточным предложением, имеет характер необязательной дополнительной информации. В этом случае следует использовать только союз which.
Стоит еще также отметить, что конкретизирующую информацию не нужно выделять запятыми, она как бы составляет единое целое со всем предложением, в то время как необязательные (дополнительные) сведения выделяются с обеих сторон запятыми.
your darn crazy.
Thus, in the sum we use “that” or “which” in the identifying clauses; In none-identifying (additional) sentences we should only use “which”.
The book which cost $15 was my favourite.
I bought one book.
I bought more than one book.
Explain please
let me explain,Alex;
1-The book,which cost $15,was my favourite(I bought one book)
2-The book which cost $15 was my favourite (I bought more than one book)
Note:if a relative clause is located between two commas,it gives extra information.In this case(for the firt sentence) we understand that we have only one book
Ok but when speaking, we don’t see commas at all)) i’ve tried to do the quiz without putting much attention on commas and just understand the different meanings and choose a correct form. 7 of 10 oups…i failed
thank you so much.. I learn new lessons.
thank you so much , i can understand the difference between identifying and non identifying clause .
Thank you so much!!
Your lesson always have helped me^^
Hi Alex thanks for lesson
you are the best in this field
thanks a lot for your good teaching
It is a great lesson.
9 out of 10. But I have a question… The answer of the first question is ”I saw a speeding car, that really startled me.” Why?
so confused and difficult to use in common speech…I need to thing about it all the time when I speak! I will be practice,Thanks Alex)
i have to check it out again :(
my scored 5/10
hey teacher. i’m from mongolia. maybe, you don’t know. my mongolian teacher tought me, that and which are same. i tested your test, and i scored 2 out of 10. i really don’t good understand. everyday, i watch engvid.com. my grammar skill isn’t good, help me. i want to give EILTS.
thank you
Thank you Alex
but why in the first question letter B is correct?
Hi Alex. Greeting you from Azerbaijan. Your lessons help me to improve my English, thnx you a lot!
Please, explain differences between Lay and Lie.
Good Luck! We Love U :)
Oh Jeez! I’ve scored 5 out of 10 :(
What a fail. By the way, is not it a mistake that you wrote ”The laptop, which cost $500, is a Toshiba.”?
Shouldn’t we have written ”which costS” since we’re talking about the single laptop? It confused me, really. Can somebody make it clean? Thanks!
well done sir
I’d the same score :(
You are the best teacher I ever had!
This class is very nice. Alex he is a good teacher. am the fan of alex..
your an Indian i suppose, you should be writing better English than this sandeep.
Hi Alex
I just want to know about the 1st testing question.Why coma is used in case of an identifying clause.I am confused.Would you please help me?
thank you very much!!!!!!!!
Hey mister teacher.Not everybody on youtube is an English teacher.Silly test.9 out of 10 anyway
Thanks Alex ….. I have to review the lesson.
Thanks a lot Alex. Exactly what I was looking for!)
what were you looking for juliange.
such lovely and clear voice.
The most difficult lesson ever on this site, at least for me. . .
Iron in the fire quenched , the person – in need.
thanks a lot Alex!
Hi, Mr. Alex, your lesson was just GREAT. thanks. But, I’m confused about (Many people are happier alone, which is not surprising) would you explain it alittle bit more, please? thanks
Thanx a lot :) um delighted with these lessons :)
Brilliant, thank you
Perfect!!!!! The lessons are great! And the teachers explain effectively! I do love them all. And I would like this program run forever for me and for others.I am Cambodian. I love English literature. Please the god help you! Bye My Favorite Teacher, My Favorite Lessons.
I don’t understand, why the answer correct is Both 1 and 2.
Merge these two sentences into one using “which” or “that”: “I saw a camel at the zoo. It was painted red!”
1I saw a camel at the zoo that was painted red.
2I saw a camel at the zoo which was painted red.
3I saw a camel at the zoo, which was painted red.
4Both 1 and 2.
becouse he told that we can use which or that for an identifying phrase but ‘which’ with no commas and the sentences used the phrase “xxx was painted red” to identify a particular camel, “the camel that he saw” (using the lesson again).
I hope have explained well.
Well done Alex, carry on this way!
GREAT CLASS!! THANKS A LOT!! :)
thanks a lot. your teaching really is best.all can not teach english. you are one of the best teacher in the world.
It’s not so simple…
thanks for your precious information
thanks a lot , i get 9 of 10 , it is great :)
i needed it
Thank you Alex, and and I`ve got a question not related directly to this lesson:
sometimes people say “I am going to do it” or “I am going to do this” .
I`m a little bit confused of this difference. Could you pls explain .
I do love your lessons. I got all questions, WHICH YOU PREPERED FOR US, right!!!! Yahooooo!!!!
i don’t understand why teacher or administrators of the website don’t answer our questions about the lesson???? are they supposed to do it or not? a lot of us didn’t get the first question in the quiz, is anybody gonna to explain this after all?!
Olesya, you can’t use THAT in non identifying clause
Hey,, you can ask if you have any questions..
shouks at gmail dot com .. it is very easiy.. i can help you..
Thats awesome O.O
It is my life ambition to meet u in real life, Alex. U are the best teacher in the bloody world, you know. keep up the amazing work
I have fun with, result in I discovered just what I used to be having a look for. You have ended my 4 day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice day. Bye
We have a lot of commas in Russian, far more than in English. And actually I had been underestimating English commas until I watched this lesson. Thank you
I have study again.Samples of lesson are quite different than the Quiz.
I admire this website and all of you.
Really great lesson and a great quiz too, because it is longer than usual and a little bit more difficult at the end. Thank you very much!
Thank you very much. The lesson was great.
I love it, Alex.
I just may became the best writer.
Thank you,
The book which cost $15 was my favourite.
I bought one book.
I bought more than one book.
I’d love to know how the phrase “which cost $15,” necessarily implies that one purchased multiple books. While the book may have cost $15, that fact has no bearing on whether or not one purchased a single or multiple books. It is an overreaching assumption for a standardized test to assume that because one chooses to qualify a SINGLE purchase, that he or she necessarily purchased multiple books. The book, which cost $15 dollars, could have been the purchaser’s favorite book but the phrase does not imply that it was the favorite one of the books that he or she purchased. The cake qualification also fits the bill; because it is in the oven does not necessarily imply that the cake was or was not the only one purchased. I pray for those trying to learn English as secondary language. It must be incomparably frustrating but I admire the effort.
Caveat to my prior statement: the cake being in the oven doesn’t imply that one is baking two cakes. It may be in the oven but its being in the oven doesn’t mean that there is another cake in the oven at all.
This part it was really diffcult for me
I did not understand very much
Really good
Why I saw a speeding car which really startled me is wrong?
That was really good, thank you
Thank you very much for presenting these English lessons. Mr.Alex, you’re an excellent teacher. Your method of explaining lessons is excellent. These lessons are useful to everyone who is interested in improving English.
I’m Gamini from Sri Lanka
little bit confusing me
well done!!
thank you for the lessons but could you please tell me what is the deffirent between which and that please
E-mail: mhamdi_freestyle@hotmail.com
what a good lesson~
great!! ^^
The lessons which/that are given by Alex are always really good! Thank you again teacher Alex!
hi…….ronnie..in your lesson of do and does..cant we use ‘you’ in past tense.example:-you did,you din’t..i got this doubt because you did not mention it..
thanks for the lesson mr alex..
Really really good lesson for me.
Thanks
Nice one Alex!!
So nice and interesting way of teaching a language!!!
you are a good teacher
thank you very much..this lesson really help me to understand using both that and which…
Thank you Mr. Alex
That was an excellent lesson, I hope you make more lessons like that. God Bless You.
Gr8 lesson though I haven’t scored good
thx Alex
v informative lesson
What a great lesson! Thanks a lot!
Hi Alex. May I ask a question? Sentence: I want to ask you about what happend yesterday.(Using “about” in this sentence correctly or not correctly?)
I was understand.
Give me a break an Indian. you should have said “I understood”.
Hello, Alex. Could you explain the difference between “that” and “what”. For example, “You can not buy all what/that you need”. What is better to use and why? I thought I had to use “what” here. But in your RESOURCES I found out that the right variant is “that”. Why?
I got only 70%
2 and 3rd are similar, A house which has a garage is the kind I want, correct without comma, and the 3rd one with comma such as The book, which is written by Stephen King, is on sale. why this difference
I GOT 8 CORRECT OUT OF 10 THANKS ALEX
hi, alek. actuaaly i cant undrstand 6 quiz this answer both 1 and 2. how com.plz tell me?
Very nice lesson!
Thank you very much Alex!
Take care!
Great lesson. The last 2 questions’ answers are wrong though.
A cake is only baking when its in the oven. The other cakes outside the oven is not baking yet. Therefor the person is only baking 1 cake.
And you have to be more specific in the answers to the 10th question. The answers does not refer to what i bought >yesterday<. The answers should be, "I bought one kind of tea yesterday" and "I bought more than one kind of tea yesterday". The current answers tells us about how much tea was bought in our lifes so far and not just yesterday.
Thanks for your great videos and quizzes :)
hey guys, I’m a newcomer here.
Could you help me to check these following sentences, whether they’re right or wrong.. I just learned when we can use which and that.
1. The Amazing spiderman, which was played few weeks ago, I think is the worst episode of Spiderman movie history.
2. Spiderman movie that starred by Andrew garfield as Peter parker and just played few weeks ago I think is the worst episode of Spiderman movie history.
I’m waiting your correction guys, thanks before.. ^^
1. In my opinion, The Amazing Spider-Man, which played a few weeks ago, is the worst chapter in Spider-Man movie history.
2. The Spider-Man movie that starred Andrew Garfield as Peter Parker and that just played a few weeks ago is the worst movie in Spider-Man movie history.
The second one is really long and works better in speaking than in writing.
Excellent lesson. It is one of these lesson that really opens my mind. But please, I have only one simple question. Is it possible to use other verb (not to be) after the clause? ej: the movie that I saw _made_ me fell bad.
Thank you any way. If you visit México don’t care about contact me. I’ll really feel good to host you. I leave close to Coyoacan, It is very close to Frida Calo museum. I have learned so much with all of your classes and I need to thank in any way.
hii alex… ur lessons are so good..
could you pls explain where to use MAY and MIGHT…?
i dont understand why the ans is 3rd option… could u pls xplain..
Merge these two sentences into one with either “which” or “that”: “Many people are happier alone. This is not surprising.”
1.Many people are happier alone, that is not surprising.
2.Many people are happier alone which is not surprising.
3.Many people are happier alone, which is not surprising.
4.Many people are happier alone that is not surprising.
Hello, there, I would like to share some my own opinions.
In 3rd option , the sentence “Many people are happier alone” could be stand alone as a independent sentence, and “which is not surprising” is a “non-essential identifying” clause that can be ignored without any problem to understand the whole sentence. So it should be a comma and which…surprising clause on the second part.
didn’t we say we use “that” only with identifying clauses? but in this quiz, I am confused of question number. Can get an explanation please?
I didn’t get that too
Didn’t we say we use “that” only with identifying clauses?But in the above quiz, we used it with an non-identifying clause. what will be the reason? Can I get some explanation please?
You’re correct. In the above example, option A is incorrect.
Good lesson, thanks Alex.
You got 8 correct out of 10
I love the lesson but I really don’t understand what is the relationship between numbers and that or which ..
7. The laptop, which cost $500, is a Toshiba.
I have one laptop.
I have more than one laptop.
8. The book which cost $15 was my favourite.
I bought one book.
I bought more than one book.
9. The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
I am baking one cake.
I am baking more than one cake.
10. The tea, which I bought yesterday, is peppermint.
I bought one kind of tea.
I bought more than one kind of tea.
>>
please explain this to me..
9/10, wow!
he teacher
thanks for every thing .i was understanding in your lessons you’r great the shanks alot
Dear Alex, I did wrong in Q8 and Q9. It would by good if you can provide any explanation to support the correct answer. Thanks!
thanks :)
hello. the lesson was really helpful. could you clarify why in question 1 there is a coma before the word that?
The question was to identify the incorrect sentence.
I am still confused with using “that and which”, the only thing i can do is to see if there is a comma in the sentence :(
I thought I understood a little.. nevertheless you can add my QiE number 396582310 to discuss this question with me , :D.
But the coma is an essential indicator (if I have understood the lesson :)
Thank you Alex, it is very useful.
Very good !
Sometimes it is hard to distinct identifying clause.e.g., I saw a cat. It’s OK. If the given condition is : In the zoo, there are a lot of animals that startle me, including a cat that has two tails.
If I was asked to jointed two sentences into one with either that or which, I would think it is a identifying clause needed because of ‘ that’ which is only used in identifying clause.
But the given sentences asked to joint together were : Many people are happier alone. This is not surprising . An non-identifying clause which gives more idea to the whole main clause sounds more reasonable: More people are happier alone, which is not surprising; identifying clause must be put at the end and closed to the noun which modifies. Can I conclude that the common sense is priority, can’t I ? Please , put your eye to this post and share your opinion. Great thanks!
Forget the immediate above-one which I just posted because I misunderstood ‘ either which or that ‘: treated it is a hint of selection of identifying clause.
thank you so much, Mr. Alex.
This video,which I watched it on today, was really beneficial about how to use that and which.
Thanks Alex
Alex Sir. I have got 70/100.I know that in 1 question I made simple mistake where I have to put comma(,). 3rd time I have got 70/100 but next time I will try to get 100/100.
With regards
Abhinav
I am unable to understand the difference between “which” and “that”. I didn’t get a clear idea. Could anyone elaborate with more examples.
Thank you teacher!!
Hello there everybody..!!
Great lesson. I love the method you teach.
However I do not think that your answer number 1 in the quiz is right. In addition, can you explain more the answer 8 and 9? Thank so much
Hi Alex, I’m wondering whether you’ve made a mistake on the #1 question of the quiz, because I’m stuck with these answers, they don’t seem to make sense to me, may be I’m wrong, but please reply, I’m so confused, Thank you.
Thank you.
Thanks teacher
very good lesson
thanks, please let me know, when we can use the relative clauses as connective?
Alex, I think you could better the examples, clauses and non identyfing are confusing to understand diferences.
Alex, these examples looks me confusing.
The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
I am baking one cake.
I am baking more than one cake.
I did’t understand why was the answer b may you please explain to me this and thank you for your lesson Mr.Alex
I got 6 out 10 definitely I am a little bit confused
Thank you Mr Alex for your lesson and still iM confused about Identifying and Non identifying Clause so could you plz… brief it again for me?????
Hi Alex .. I think there is a point you didn’t menion it in your video .. that identifing clause means we have more than one thing, while non-identifying clause maens we have just one thing .. as example ..
the laptop,which cost 500$,is a Toshipa ,
means that I have one laptop
is that true ?
Dear Alex, could you tell me what’s the meaning of the last four questions?
Could you explain the reason of using a comma in the second sentence of question one?
I also have the same question; number one should not have a comma, so, was this an editing error or the software is drunk ;-)
I appreciate you so much that I just want to stand up and applaud you for years,(for all your work).
Awesome lesson. Thank you
thanks so much again and again
I don’t know,I got only 60 %.
Thanks a lot
9/10 not too bad.
Thank you for your lesson.
I’ve just known the meaning of identifining, non-identifing relative clause.
this lesson is raelly hard its not easy to defferentiate which one is right and which one is wrong any any way thank you su much i reaally like your leesson
Thank you! You helped me a lot!
thank you very much Alex, I’ve really well understood the (no more) tricky point…I’m deeply grateful :)
Dear. Sir,
I have got nine correct out of ten. I wonder if i might ask you a question. I do not understain very well the first. Maybe is a restrective clause or not? I did see a coma but I did wrong that. i pay my respect to you. Thank you kindly. H
before ‘ve watched this video.i was really confused that when we should use “that”,when we should use “which”.thank you so much
wonderful lesson. Your videos are really useful.
Another wonderful lesson! 9/10 Thanks.
Great lesson.thanx Alex
Where can I watch the previous lesson? What previous lesson did you meantion in this video?
I am really upset. I got 30.
Please I can’t understand the last four questions in the quiz.Would you explain them please?
Now I understand the difference between identifying clause and non-identifying clause.
Thank you.
I got :D
its not necessary . i didn’t like your teaching
goo zoo
I’m bad in this lesson. I’m sorry Alex.
A kind of complex it.
very good teacher ,very good lesson,
Alex, you are a great teacher.
Tiny
how can i know the correct answer. pls give the explanation for the answers
it was very good lesson. Hopefully your tips will help me in the exam in the exam on wednesday
Difficult lesson. After analyse I made second attempt and got 9 from 10
First of all, I would like to this amazing site engvid.
Just a suggestion: I would like to have a feedback about how much exercises exists and how much is completed.
Thanks!
Hi Alex, my fav. teacher
I totally got ur lesson on the video but i could not get a good score on its exam.(3/10)
I think the way u thaught this subject needs more clarification…or the questions and the video are not on the same level.
plz make another video about it.
Hi Alex Q The lesson is very very BAD. (((
Thank you very much teacher .
I got 100. Again. Yes yes yes. Thanks
no 1 (a) IS correct, but is not the answer we are looking for in the context of this lesson. It looks to me as if I was startled by a speeding car. I think a less ambiguous question would be in order.
no 2 is almost yoda-speak. I cannot believe anyone would use that sentence when attempting to say “I want a house with a garage.”
no 3 is another clumsy way to say something simple.
People would be more likely to say “Stephen King’s book is on sale”?
no 4 seems a horribly clumsy way to say “I saw a cat with two tails.”
nos 5 & 6 can be merged without using which or that.
I use colons and semicolons, they’re much easier for sentence splicing.
no 7 – it is clear to me from “The Laptop” rather than anything else that there’s only one laptop being discussed. If there was another, then the sentence would begin “This/That Laptop”
no 8 is a giveaway because you need more than one of whatever it is to have a favourite. eg nobody ever talks about their favourite mother because they only have one mother.
no 9 isn’t quite so clear cut as it seems.The cake we are talking about might be the last one we are baking today, whereas all the others are sitting on wire racks cooling off (and definitely not baking). So in that sense we are baking only one cake.
Another problem is as follows: we don’t know if the oven can hold more than one cake at a time. If there’s only space for one, then in another sense we are only baking one cake.
And a third problem is this: it is not specified whether the oven is on or off, or whether it is working or not. Clearly we cannot bake any cakes if the oven is broken or turned off. Talking about the cake being “ready” does not help clarify matters, because “ready” might mean “ready to throw away.”
oh, and if the oven is turned up too high, then we are burning, not baking.
no 10 – oh, I’ll let you off that one. But I’d like to know if “peppermint” means colour or flavour.
Amazing lesson,”That” and “Which” all your lessons are amazing.
though I am not confused with ‘which and that’ lesson, but I am confused with the sentence in the last question.
The tea, which I bought yesterday, is peppermint.
why we used ‘is’? why not ‘was’?
I was made to believe that we should not mix present and past tense in one sentence.
Any advice?
By the way, your lesson is very interesting.
What a great lesson. Thank you. Alex! you’re the best!!
you engvid guys make things easier! you make the topic which confused me for so many yrs so easy to understand. it’s amazing useful! thx u a lot, teacher
Simply Awesome!!
Hi Alex, thanks for your english lesson videos. It will help a lot of your viewers. But on this video, I have 2 questions.
On point # 8 – The book which cost $15 was my favorite.
The answer is: I bought more than one book.
The subject “book” is singular and the verb “was” is also in singular form. Based on the question, how to justify that the answer is correct?
On point # 9: The cake which is in the oven right now should be ready in 10 minutes.
Answer : I am baking more than one cake.
The subject “cake” is also singular.
Question: same as point 8 above.
Hello, teacher Alex.
Could you please explain the question 6? Why can’t I choose the third option?
Best regards!
I like this lesson
“The book which cost $15 was my favourite.”
Wouldn’t it be: “The book which costs $15 was my favourite.”
Yes if you’re speaking in the present. If you want to use the past, it’s “cost.” :)
Thanks Alex! Grate lesson!
it was hard
your teaching stzle is very nice. Thanks for lession.
it is a wonderful class. could you also explain how to use “in which”? Thanks.
Many thanks Alex
Hi! I have a questions that may seem out of place, but I really have the bug.
In the first example you use the verb see and not watch. I am use to say “watch a movie” because I was thaugh that it was incorrect to use the verb see when refering to movies or tv.
Coul you please explain when to use watch and see when refering to movies or tv?
Thank you :)
Excuse me sir! I would think “I saw a speeding car, which really startled me” is the best answer for question I by reason of the comma, plus the fact that ” I saw a speeding car” is an independent clause by itself and needs no more identification. Am I right?
The 7th sentence is incorrect. The laptop, which cost 500$, is a Toshiba. “which cost 500$” is a defining part and it is not a modification, so there are no need in comas. Would you understand what laptope I meant if I wrote “the laptop is a Toshiba”? Without this extra information about the price we can’t understand which laptop is a Toshiba. So according to this I deffently have more than one laptop, probably that another laptop which cost 400$ is a Dell.
Thanks a lot for this great lesson !!!!!
Dear Alex,
You were in this lesson excellent!
I really was needing to know the difference between them when using in clauses. So you saved me! Thanks I’ll remember you forever!
sir, in the quiz, the first sentence, how can the answer be ” ,that startled me ” be right while I’ve learnt to NOT EVER USE COMMA BEOFRE THAT
Can someone explain question 9?
I watched this video twice on May 10, 2021, and I took the quiz after watching it once. I got 10 correct out of 10.
I watched this video one more time on June 13, 2021.
I watched this video one more time on June 26, 2021, and I took the quiz after watching it once. I got 10 correct out of 10.
I’ve got only 3 out of 10. I confused 7 questions but that mistakes make me learn more master :).
Thank you very much for
the explanation of the material. It’s really useful for me )))
I enjoyed it a lot!.